What arrived, and where was it in the case?
A buyer opens a shipping case and finds one crushed retail carton in a corner. Photograph the case exterior, the location of the carton and its unopened pouch before separating them. Count the units actually examined and record whether nearby cartons show the same mark. Keep the carrier’s delivery note with these observations. Cosmetic GMP guidance includes shipment from the manufacturer. Agree with the warehouse who will preserve the receiving evidence once the delivery changes hands.
ISO (2007) · Cosmetics good manufacturing practices / ISO 22716

Image credits
Mengzhen Xing, Han Liu, Fanda Meng, Yuning Ma, Suohui Zhang, Yunhua Gao, Lianhua Fu, Junfeng Li, Muhammad Rizwan Younis, Changzhou Chen and Xiaohong Chen · Image source · CC BY 4.0 · Cropped to the original packaging photograph in panel A and converted to WebP.
Which layer appears to have moved?
A dented retail carton, a displaced tray and a changed patch surface describe three different observations. Label photographs by layer and include the sample identifier. A closed outer pack may hide the cause of an internal mark, while a torn corner may leave every patch undisturbed. Research comparing commercial cosmetic patches evaluated physical integrity across products. For your own shipment, attach the before-dispatch and receiving views of the same pack revision so a reviewer can locate the change.
Which comparison can narrow the investigation?
Request an unopened retained unit from the same pilot lot and pack revision. If the same mark appears on that unit, review the pack fit and the pre-dispatch images. If the retain looks different, record the route and handling history as investigation leads. Neither observation proves a cause by itself. A laboratory storage study such as Anjani and colleagues’ container comparison addresses its specified conditions. A distribution decision needs evidence about the actual pack and journey.
Anjani et al. (2024) · The MAP-box storage study / Drug Delivery and Translational Research
Prepare your inquiry
A useful damage review preserves the chain from the shipping case to the individual retail unit.